Although Valentine’s Day is centered around packaged chocolate muscle men, colorful sweethearts, and pink frosting-topped cupcakes galore, it’s time to start making heartfelt treats from scratch for your significant other and/or loved ones. Get rid of the artificial chemicals and sugars that go into making V-Day so sweet and use whole, low-sugar ingredients such as cacao, fresh fruit, raw desserts, and especially peanut butter.
If you choose to make your own V-Day treats, it’s important to use healthy, wholesome ingredients that provide nutritional benefits. When you can find a natural peanut butter like Crazy Richard’s with only one ingredient, you can feel safe using it for any and all kinds of sweet treats, including straight out of the jar with a spoon.
Another way to avoid a sugar-high during this special holiday is to politely request your loved ones to refrain from giving you candy, that is if you typically receive a gift, and instead, request something non-food related. Seem a little ridiculous? You’ll thank me once you’ve successfully bypassed (pun-intended) all of the overly consumed artificial sweet treats that Valentine’s Day has to offer.
Try making the low-sugar recipe below this Valentine’s Day! **I bought the heart-shaped mold on Amazon.

Valentine's Day Chocolate PB Hearts (Dairy Free)
Ingredients
- Chocolate:5 tbsp coconut oil¼ cup cacao powder1 tsp maple syrup
- Peanut butter filling:½ tbsp maple syrup½ tsp vanilla1 tsp coconut oil2 tbsp coconut flour¼ cup Crazy Richard’s Creamy Peanut Butter
Instructions
-
Melt coconut oil over the stove or in the microwave in a small bowl for 20-30 seconds. After, stir in cacao powder and 1 tsp maple syrup until thoroughly combined.
-
Using a teaspoon measure, pour a very small amount of chocolate mixture into the heart-shaped mold to cover only the bottom. Once all bases are filled, place mold in freezer on a flat surface for 5-10 minutes.
-
Prepare filling: mix together ½ tbsp maple syrup, vanilla, remaining coconut oil together in a bowl. Add in coconut flour to combine, then fold in Crazy Richard’s Creamy Peanut Butter.
-
Remove the heart-shaped mold from the freezer. Then, using a small spoon place enough of the filling mixture to cover the middle of the chocolate base, but leaving enough room around the outside for the liquid chocolate to fill.
-
Once all of the hearts are topped with the filling, use a teaspoon to pour the liquid chocolate mixture over the top of each peanut butter ball, until it reaches the surface of the mold.
-
Place entire mold in the freezer again for 15 minutes to harden.
-
Once done, pop the chocolates out of the mold and enjoy right away or, store in a glass tupperware in the freezer for up to 2 months.
Omg the heart shaped chocolates look so good! #peanutbutter is what I’m hoping to win from the giveaway! I’m so glad to have found another blog that does dairy free recipes thanks to my dairy allergy!
These look amazing! Better than store bought for sure. 🙂 #peanutbutter ❤
So excited to make these as a treat for the hubs. ?❤️ #spiralizer
Such a great recipe! Hoping I can win the giveaway for #CrazyRichards to be able to make this!!
Yum! What a cute and fun Valentine treat! Might have to make this for my future class of kids! Thanks 🙂
OMG!!!! No better combination than PB and Chocolate so much love!!!!!!!!:)
Obsessed! Must try this!!
Totally making these! ? #crazyrichardspb #inspiralizer #kouzinifoods
Leaving a comment for the giveaway 🙂 I am a senior in dietetics right now, and finally completed DICAS which is due Wednesday! Inspired by your beautiful instagram and vast following. Looking forward to being a #futureRD
GOOD LUCK!! 🙂 You’re so sweet, thank you <3
honestly love your site! it’s fun, eye-catching, and theres SO MUCH YUM to look through!!
You’re so sweet, thank you! 🙂
Love these! #rootznutritionprotienpowder
Wow love this, trying it for the fam bam.
These look amazing! Perfect chocolate peanut butter treat. #rootznutrition
I’m so excited I found your instagram! You are serious #goals! I can’t wait to try the recipes! #theinspiralizer ? #inspiralized ?
You’re so sweet, thanks girl!!
Thanks for the valentines recipe! Looks so easy and so delicious! ? I enjoy following you on insta, you’re truly inspiring and following food bloggers like keep me on track. So thank you! #rootz please!
Aw thank you so so much! 🙂
These look so amazing! Can’t wait to try them out for Valentine’s Day.
Yummm I need to try these for Valentine’s Day!
These look delish, can’t wait to try them! Instagram @funka404
These look delicious!! #paleoprotein or #crazyrichardspb
#crazyrichardspb These sound amazing! Yes to the healthy fats in PB and the homemade chocolate in this recipe! I’d love to win a jar of Crazy Richards and makes these for my hubby. ?
Omg these look so good and so easy to make! Definitely going to try them!
Yum! I’d love to win the #makingitgrain tote bag 🙂
Can’t wait to give these a try!
These look so good! Would love to win the #Inspiralizer and #MakinItGrain tote
#crazyrichardspb ?
#CrazyRichards is my absolute favorite peanut butter of all time! These look delicious!! I think I’ll have to try making them 🙂
Hi!
What’s the name of the brand making the molds? Do they work for gummies too?
#rootznutrition
I want to win the #inspiralizer!! Happy birthday!!
#crazyrichardpeanutbutter yum yum, I would love to try it!
I am so excited to make these! I received my heart molds by prime yesterday just in time for valentines day. I would love to win #crazyrichardspb to fill them or #rootznutrition so that I can stay fit to work my treats off, although this looks like a great lower sugar way to fulfill my chocolate indulgence.
Happy birthday?!!! I made these for V day and love them! Thanks for the recipe! ? And I would love any of the primers but definitely the inspiralizer ❤️
I’m so happy you made these and loved them!!! 🙂
#crazyrichards is my favorite! All natural and one ingredient, they make my favorite nut butters
HAPPY BIRTHDAY! ? #inspiralizer #crazyrichards
#rootznutrition
Definitely going to try this out for my galantines party! Looks amaaazing
Love the recipe being vegan with no junk! ? ? #inspiralizer #crazyrichards
#rootznutrition
Oh heck yes! I would love to make this with #crazyrichardspb ! 🙂
Happy Birthday!! Crossing my fingers for the #rootznutrition preworkout & protein powder
An #inspiralizer to make a delicious dinner before eating these chocolate peanut butter hearts would really sweeten the deal. I hope your birthday was full of good eats!
I want to win the #rootznutrition!! Happy birthday Rachael, hope it was a good one!
These would be great with #crazyrichards!
I would love to win the rootz nutrition giveaway so that I can make your waffle recipe, also wanted to wish you a happy birthday, your page is full of great recipes and advise so thank you for that. #perfectwafflesplease
I can’t wait to try these!!!! Hope you had a lovely birthday! Hoping to win the #peanutbutter of course or #rootznutrition protein powder!! ❤
Happy Birthday! You are so inspiring. I would love to win #kouzinfoods
I’m definitely down for the #crazyrichardspb and these’ll be on my list to make!
These look so delicious! And so creative! I’d love to win the #rootznutrition paleo chocolate banana nut protein powder. And happy birthday 🙂
Love your Instagram page and all the fun recipes 🙂 hoping to win the #spiralizer and #bag!
These look so delicious! I want to win #crazyrichardspb so I can make these!!
I also want to win a #rachaelsgoodeats tote bag so I can carry my treats with me 🙂
Okay last comment! I want to win #theinspiralizer too so I can cook from my Inspiralized cookbook (probably should’ve waited to get the cookbook until I had the Inspiralizer!)
I would so make these with the #crqzyrichardspb if I won it ?
Made these yesterday! Super yummy! Would love to win the #proteinpowder
These sound amazing! I love any chocolate/PB combo 🙂 Really hoping to win and try some #crazyrichardspb since it sounds much healthier than the brands I normally buy!
ah these are to die for! Need to makes these asap! I would love to win the #peanutbutter!